The Cholesterol Myth

Jan 11, 2024By Functional Medicine Consulting

FM

The longstanding association between cholesterol levels and cardiovascular health has been a prevailing narrative in medical discourse. However, many insights challenge the conventional wisdom, revealing a nuanced perspective on the intricate relationship between cholesterol and heart-related conditions.

Despite the pervasive belief linking cholesterol to cardiovascular diseases, comprehensive studies have unveiled a paradox. Approximately 50% of individuals who succumbed to heart disease or stroke displayed normal to low total cholesterol levels. This revelation sparks a reevaluation of the simplistic correlation between cholesterol metrics and cardiovascular risk.

While cholesterol has been cast as a culprit in heart-related conditions, the emerging understanding suggests a more complex interplay of factors. Beyond numerical thresholds, the role of cholesterol in the body's intricate processes, such as hormone and brain chemical synthesis and repairing tissue damage, adds complexity to the narrative. This becomes particularly pertinent when considering interventions like cholesterol-lowering drugs, which may inadvertently impact these essential physiological functions.

The common classification of cholesterol into "good" HDL (High-Density Lipoprotein) and "bad" LDL (Low-Density Lipoprotein) oversimplifies the intricate role these lipoproteins play in our bodies. Often deemed harmful, LDL is a transportation vehicle, shuttling cholesterol from the liver to the body's tissues, which plays a crucial role in various functions. 

Conversely, HDL is labeled as beneficial because it transports excess or leftover cholesterol from the tissues back to the liver for recycling. In essence, LDL and HDL are naturally produced carriers that facilitate the essential movement of cholesterol between the liver and body tissues. Labelling them as good or bad oversimplifies their intricate functions.

An elevated LDL indicates the body's response to tissue damage, suggesting a reparative process rather than being inherently harmful. Blaming cholesterol for cardiovascular disease, heart disease, heart attacks, and strokes is akin to blaming the fire trucks for the fire. This significantly oversimplifies the complex processes and highlights the need for a more nuanced understanding of cholesterol's importance in our health. This brings us to a crucial realization – understanding the multifaceted role of cholesterol in the body is paramount for holistic health.

The "desirable" total blood cholesterol level is typically less than 200 mg/dL. To better understand this in absolute terms, we can use a conversion factor to express this level in milligrams per liter (mg/L), where 1 mg/dL is equivalent to 10 mg/L. Therefore, 200 mg/dL of blood cholesterol can be expressed as 2000 mg/L. Considering the average blood volume in a person ranges from 5 to 7 liters, the total amount of cholesterol in the blood would be 2000 mg/L multiplied by 5 to 7 liters, resulting in a range of 10,000 mg to 14,000 mg.

Now, here's the twist: The liver uses the HMG-CoA reductase enzyme to produce most of the body's cholesterol. Lipoprotein particles in the bloodstream, specifically LDL, carry this cholesterol to different tissues. These particles are crucial as they deliver cholesterol to cells throughout the body, facilitating the production of cell membranes, hormones, neurotransmitters, and bile acids. 

Although cholesterol levels in the blood provide valuable information about cardiovascular health and disease risk, they only represent a small fraction of the overall cholesterol present in the body. Most cholesterol is present within cells and plays an essential role in cellular structure and function.

Since the blood only contains a fraction of the body's total cholesterol, it is safe to assume that the total amount of cholesterol in the body is significantly greater than the 10,000-14,000 mg estimated for the blood. Therefore, it is evident that the total cholesterol content of the body would far exceed the cholesterol found in the blood.

Let's consider the cholesterol content of an egg, which is around 185 mg. However, only about 10% of the cholesterol from food sources like eggs is absorbed by the body. This means that even if we consider the entire cholesterol content of an egg, only a small fraction of it, approximately 18.5 mg, is actually absorbed by the body.

When we look at the bigger picture of total blood and body cholesterol levels, adding 18.5 mg from consuming one egg is quite negligible. Total cholesterol levels in the blood range from 10,000 to 14,000 mg, and the entire body has even more cholesterol than that. Therefore, the small amount of cholesterol from dietary sources like eggs is insignificant compared to the total amount of cholesterol in the body.

It is common for medical physicians and dietitians to recommend limiting the consumption of eggs and other foods based on their cholesterol content. However, many studies have convincingly proven the ineffectiveness of such recommendations, as the impact of these individual foods on overall cholesterol levels in the body is remarkably insignificant.